Back to Insights

Self-Employed Tax Investigation: When Does HMRC Investigate the Self-Employed?

By admin
28 Sep 2023
Tax Investigation

Are you self-employed and worried about HMRC tax investigations?

The world of taxation can be a complex and daunting one for the self-employed. In the United Kingdom, HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) is responsible for collecting taxes and ensuring that individuals and businesses comply with relevant tax laws. For the self-employed, this means accurately reporting their income and expenses and paying the correct amount of tax.

While most self-employed individuals are diligent about meeting their tax obligations, there are times when HMRC may launch a tax investigation. These investigations can be a source of anxiety and stress, but understanding the triggers and the process can help ease some of those concerns. In this article, we will explore when and why HMRC investigates the self-employed and what to expect if you find yourself facing an investigation.

1. Red Flags and Triggers

HMRC conducts tax investigations to ensure that individuals and businesses are paying the correct amount of tax. There are various triggers and red flags that can prompt HMRC to initiate an investigation into a self-employed individual’s tax affairs. Some common reasons include:

1.1. Discrepancies in Tax Returns

One of the most common triggers for a tax investigation is discrepancies or inconsistencies in a self-employed individual’s tax returns. This can include underreporting income, overclaiming expenses, or failing to declare all sources of income.

1.2. Random Selection

In some cases, HMRC may select individuals for investigation randomly. While this may seem unfair, it is part of HMRC’s efforts to ensure that the tax system is fair and that everyone is paying their fair share.

1.3. Tips and Whistleblowers

HMRC may receive tips or information from whistleblowers about potential tax evasion or fraud. This can lead to an investigation if the information is credible and suggests wrongdoing.

1.4. Industry or Sector Focus

Sometimes, HMRC may focus its efforts on specific industries or sectors where tax evasion is more prevalent. If you work in an industry that is currently under scrutiny, you may be more likely to face an investigation.

1.5. Previous Non-Compliance

If you have a history of non-compliance with tax laws, such as late or missing tax returns or unpaid taxes, HMRC may be more inclined to investigate your tax affairs.

1.6. Anomalies in Financial Information

Unusual or significant changes in your financial information, such as a sudden decrease in reported income or a sharp increase in expenses, can raise red flags and trigger an investigation.

1.7 Reports from foreign tax authorities

HMRC now received information from foreign tax authorities. As UK residents are liable to UK tax on all worldwide income and gains, foreign authorities may advise HMRC on income an individual has received from offshore. This will then be compared to the figures disclosed on your return.

2. The Investigation Process

If HMRC decides to investigate your tax affairs, you will typically be notified in writing. This notification will provide details about the scope and nature of the investigation and may request specific information and documents. It’s essential to respond promptly and cooperate with HMRC throughout the process. Here is an overview of what to expect during a tax investigation:

2.1. Initial Contact

The initial contact from HMRC will inform you about the investigation and provide instructions on what you need to do. You may be asked to provide documents, records, and other information related to your income, expenses, and taxes.

2.2. Review of Documents

HMRC will review the documents and information you provide, to assess the accuracy of your tax returns. They will check for discrepancies and inconsistencies and may ask for further clarification if needed.

2.3. Interviews and Meetings

In some cases, HMRC may conduct interviews or meetings with you to discuss your tax affairs further. These interviews may be conducted in person, over the phone, or via video conference.

2.4. Assessment of Tax Liability

Based on their findings, HMRC will assess your tax liability. If they determine that you owe additional taxes, penalties, or interest, they will provide you with a breakdown of the amounts owed.

2.5. Appeals and Dispute Resolution

If you disagree with HMRC’s assessment, you have the right to appeal their decision. There are formal procedures for appealing, and it’s advisable to seek professional advice if you intend to dispute the outcome of the investigation.

2.6. Settlement or Legal Action

In some cases, HMRC and the taxpayer may reach a settlement agreement to resolve the tax dispute. If an agreement cannot be reached, HMRC may pursue legal action to recover the taxes owed.

3. Tips for Dealing with a Tax Investigation

Facing an HMRC tax investigation can be a stressful experience, but there are steps you can take to make the process smoother and less daunting:

3.1. Seek Professional Advice

Consider hiring a qualified tax advisor or accountant with experience in dealing with tax investigations. They can provide valuable guidance and represent your interests during the investigation.

3.2. Organise Your Records

Ensure that your financial records, including income and expense documentation, are well-organised and readily accessible. This will make it easier to respond to HMRC’s requests for information.

3.3. Cooperate Fully

Cooperating with HMRC is essential throughout the investigation. Be responsive to their requests for information and provide accurate and complete details.

3.4. Review Your Tax Returns

Take the time to review your previous tax returns and correct any errors or discrepancies. Being proactive in addressing any mistakes can help demonstrate your commitment to compliance.

3.5. Consider a Disclosure

If you discover errors or omissions in your tax returns before HMRC initiates an investigation, you may consider making a voluntary disclosure. This can lead to more favourable treatment from HMRC.

3.6. Stay Informed

Keep yourself informed about tax laws and regulations relevant to your business or industry. Staying up to date can help you avoid mistakes that could trigger an investigation.

4. Conclusion

While facing an HMRC tax investigation can be a nerve-wracking experience for the self-employed, it’s important to remember that not all investigations result in adverse outcomes. Many investigations are routine and end with no additional tax liability. However, it’s crucial to take the process seriously, cooperate fully with HMRC, and seek professional advice if needed.

The key to navigating a tax investigation successfully is to maintain accurate and comprehensive financial records, review your tax returns for errors, and stay informed about tax laws. By doing so, you can reduce the likelihood of triggering an investigation and ensure that you are meeting your tax obligations as a self-employed individual.

If you are self-employed and looking to get ahead of the curb this year than reach out to a member of our team who would me more than happy to assist. Contact us here

For more tips on being self-employed keep an eye on our social pages Facebook Instagram and LinkedIn

Back to Insights

Get our latest tax articles direct to your inbox

Edge Newsletter

What best describes you?